I Broke My Golden Rule in the YMCA Sauna

There I was in the sauna, just trying to get my heat exposure in, when Sauna Bro #1 starts dropping “health knowledge” on anyone who'd listen. The confidence was impressive. The advice, not so much…

Bottom Line UP Front (BLUF)

• Sauna ≠ Zone 2 cardio: Your heart rate rises in the sauna, but you’re not building aerobic capacity—no muscle contraction, no VO2 max improvement. Sauna complements cardio through different mechanisms like improved endothelial function.

• Session length matters: Research supports 20 minute sessions. Anything beyond 45 minutes doesn’t seem to provide additional benefits.

• Lactic acid isn’t sweated out: Your body clears lactate through the liver and muscles within 30-60 minutes post-exercise. Sweat is 99% water; your kidneys and liver handle detox.

• Heat shock proteins are real, but limited: They support immune function and may reduce respiratory illness risk—but they won’t make you immune to getting sick.

• Frequency is key: Finnish research shows 4+ sauna sessions per week significantly reduces cardiovascular and all-cause mortality. That’s the benefit worth chasing.

Before We Get Started

• If you are a Rebuilder (paid subscriber), make sure to check out the Start on Sunday series to unlock my paint-by-numbers simple system for taking your results as a Rebuilder to the next level (and never coming back).

• Learning to manage stress is one of the best upgrades you can make to your health. If you want a complete system - check out my new program Built to Handle It: A Stress Inoculation Program for Dads. 8 weeks to build real resilience that lasts. Pre-order before December 29th and save $100..

What the Sauna Bro Got Wrong

I have one rule I rarely break: I don’t give out unsolicited nutrition and health advice.

If someone asks me a question? I’m more than happy to engage. I’ll dig into the details, talk through the research, and help them figure out whatever they’re trying to accomplish. That’s different. That’s a conversation between two people trying to get somewhere.

But unsolicited advice? That’s where I’ve learned to hold back.

Over 25 years, I’ve discovered something about human nature. When people believe something about fitness or nutrition—I mean really believe it—they’re rarely open to hearing what the science actually says. They didn’t ask. They don’t want to be corrected. The conversation goes nowhere. Energy wasted.

So I stay quiet.

Yesterday, I broke that rule.

I was sitting in the sauna at the Y—something I do three times a week now as part of my overall health strategy—when a guy started holding court. Confidently sharing everything he’d learned about heat therapy, recovery, and getting lean. The other guys in there were nodding along, taking mental notes.

Most of what he said was wrong.

And that’s frustrating.

But when guys spread misinformation about why sauna works and what it actually does, it muddies the water. It makes the whole practice sound like bro-science instead of the legitimate health tool it is.

Sauna use has real, meaningful benefits backed by solid research. It’s one of the reasons I’ve made it a non-negotiable part of my weekly routine this year. Finnish studies show that regular sauna use—particularly 4+ times per week—is associated with significant reductions in cardiovascular mortality and all-cause mortality. We’re talking 40-50% reductions in risk. That’s not trivial.

After he left, I felt compelled to set the record straight with the guys still in there.

“You don’t sweat out lactic acid. That’s not how any of this works”

That actually opened the door to a nice conversation about recovery, physical activity, and the benefits of regular sauna use.

So let me break down what the Sauna Bro preached in the YMCA sauna yesterday—and what the research actually shows.

“Going in the Sauna is the Same as Doing Zone 2 Cardio”

When you sit in a sauna, your heart rate goes up. Blood pressure changes. Your cardiovascular system responds to the heat stress. A 2019 study from Martin Luther University found that these acute responses are comparable to moderate-intensity exercise.

But comparable heart rate doesn’t mean identical benefits.

Zone 2 cardio improves your aerobic capacity because your muscles are contracting, demanding oxygen, and forcing adaptations in how your body produces and uses energy. Your mitochondria get better at their job. Your heart gets more efficient at pumping blood. Your body learns to oxidize fat more effectively.

In the sauna, your heart is working harder because it’s trying to cool you down, not because your muscles need fuel. There is an increase in cardiac output BUT there’s no mechanical load on your cardiovascular system. No muscle fiber recruitment. No direct improvement in VO2 max.

That said—and this is important—sauna bathing provides cardiovascular benefits through different mechanisms. The repeated thermal stress improves endothelial function, reduces arterial stiffness, and lowers blood pressure over time. Research shows that combining sauna with exercise produces greater reductions in blood pressure than either alone.

Sauna isn’t a replacement for Zone 2 work. It’s a powerful complement to it. I do both.

Think of it like diet and exercise. It’s and not or.

“Sauna for 60 Minutes, Multiple Times a Week, is the Ultimate Recovery Cheat Code”

The word “cheat code” should be your first red flag. There are no cheat codes. There are only trade-offs and priorities.

But let’s separate the nonsense from the legitimate point buried in here.

Regular sauna use multiple times per week? That’s actually well-supported. The Finnish research showing mortality benefits was based on frequency—men who used the sauna 4-7 times per week had substantially lower cardiovascular mortality than those who used it once weekly.

But heat stress is a stressor. It’s literally in the name. This is why it needs to be managed as part of your overall program.

Sixty minutes per session? That’s where things go off the rails.

You can actually get pretty good benefits from 20 minutes per session. Studies show that benefits might plateau at around 45 minutes - You do get increases beyond 45 minutes, but they might just be increases in risk of dehydration and heat stress.

And calling anything the “ultimate recovery cheat code” oversells what sauna actually does for recovery. It can help with muscle relaxation and blood flow. But actual low-intensity movement—a 45-minute walk or easy bike ride - maybe a more effective active recovery tool.

An even better recovery tool? 60 extra minutes of sleep.

Sauna fits into a recovery protocol. It’s not a shortcut around one.

“When You Go in the Sauna, You Sweat Out Lactic Acid”

This one made me break my rule…..as my youngest would say “Come‘on son”

Let’s start with the basics: you don’t sweat out lactic acid in any meaningful way. Yes, sweat contains trace amounts of lactate—along with water, sodium, calcium, and small amounts of urea. But the idea that you’re flushing exercise-induced lactate through your sweat glands? That’s not how your body works.

Lactate clearance happens primarily through your liver and muscles. Your body is remarkably efficient at this. Through what’s called the Cori cycle, lactate is transported from your muscles to your liver, converted back to glucose, and sent back to your muscles for fuel. This happens within 30 to 60 minutes after exercise—long before you’d even get to the sauna.

And here’s the other thing: lactate isn’t even the villain it’s been made out to be. It’s not the cause of delayed onset muscle soreness—that’s from microscopic tears in muscle fibers. Your muscles actually use lactate as fuel. It’s a feature, not a bug.

The detox-through-sweat narrative is compelling because it feels intuitive. You’re sweating, you feel gross, so it must be “toxins” leaving your body. But your liver and kidneys handle the actual detoxification work. Sweat’s primary job is temperature regulation—it’s more than 99% water.

Sauna has real benefits. “Sweating out lactic acid” isn’t one of them.

“Heat Shock Proteins Activate Your Immune System, So You Don’t Get Sick”

This one contains a kernel of truth buried under oversimplification.

Heat shock proteins are real, and they matter. They’re produced when your body experiences thermal stress—increased by roughly 50% after a sauna session. Research shows they can remain elevated for up to 48 hours. And yes, there’s solid evidence they play a role in immune function—activating certain immune cells and potentially helping the body respond to pathogens.

A Finnish study found that regular sauna users had a lower risk of developing respiratory conditions like pneumonia. That’s legitimate data. Heat shock proteins have also been shown to inhibit influenza viral replication in lab studies.

But “you don’t get sick” is a massive oversell.

Your immune system is incredibly complex. Heat shock proteins are one piece of a much larger puzzle. Sleep quality, stress management, nutrition, and regular exercise all have more robust and well-documented effects on immune function.

Think of heat shock proteins as a specialized “repair squad” that your body activates when it gets really hot, tricking it into thinking it’s under stress. This squad rushes around fixing damaged cells and cleaning up “biological junk” inside your body before it can cause real problems. Basically, the heat that you expose yourself to in the sauna tricks your body to level up its defense systems, making you tougher and more resilient against disease.

The Takeaway

I’m in the sauna three days a week. It’s a commitment I made this year based on the research showing reduced cardiovascular and all-cause mortality risk. The data is compelling, and frankly, I enjoy the practice.

That’s exactly why the misinformation bothers me.

When someone tells you sauna replaces cardio, or that you’re sweating out lactic acid, or that heat shock proteins make you immune to illness—they’re making a legitimate health practice sound like snake oil. They’re giving ammunition to skeptics and confusing guys who might actually benefit from adding sauna to their routine.

Sauna works. Just not for the reasons the guy at the Y was preaching.

Use it for what it actually does: cardiovascular protection, stress reduction, potential immune support, and a forced 20 minutes where you can’t check your phone or answer emails. That last one might be the most underrated benefit of all (so don’t bring your phone in the sauna).

---